CaliToday (15/11/2025): It’s time to bench the tomato. Why trading the 'T' for a 'P' (Pickle) unlocks a world of flavor, crunch, and consistency that the classic original just can’t match.
We must first pay respects to the icon. The Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato sandwich is, without question, in the culinary hall of fame. For over a century, the BLT has been the gold standard of simple perfection a masterful symphony of salty, smoky bacon, crisp lettuce, and fatty mayonnaise, all cut by the bright, juicy sweetness of a summer tomato. It’s a sandwich that melds crunch with softness, and fat with acid, in a way that’s hard to beat.
 |
| A toasted sandwich layered with mayo, green lettuce, bacon, and tomatoes - Chas53/Getty Images |
But let's be honest. The BLT is a high-stakes gamble, and its success rests entirely on one, deeply flawed ingredient: the tomato.
A BLT with a perfect, in-season, garden-fresh heirloom tomato is a transcendent experience. A BLT with a mealy, pale, out-of-season supermarket tomato is a watery, flavorless disappointment.
The sandwich's entire integrity shouldn't depend on the calendar. We can do better.
If, as some believe, the BLT is simply a streamlined adaptation of the club sandwich, then it’s not sacred—it’s meant to be evolved. So, the next time the craving hits, it’s time to make a BLP: Bacon, Lettuce, and Pickle.
Why the Pickle Is a Perfect Upgrade
This isn't just a substitution; it's a strategic enhancement. A tomato adds a juicy element, a hint of sweetness, and some mild acidity to balance the mayo and bacon fat.
A pickle does all of that, and infinitely more.
Where the tomato is gentle and seasonal, the pickle is confident, complex, and reliable every single day of the year. It delivers a sharp, assertive acidity from its vinegar brine that slices through the richness of the bacon in a way a tomato simply can't.
But the real magic lies in its versatility. Swapping the 'T' for a 'P' blows the door wide open. You aren't just getting one flavor profile; you're gaining access to an entire pantry of them.
How to Master the Bacon, Lettuce, and Pickle Sandwich
The BLP isn't just one sandwich; it's a template for greatness. The type of pickle you choose dictates the entire flavor experience, allowing you to pair it with other ingredients.
 |
| Close up of a sandwich made with a seed covered bread loaded with pickles - Bhofack2/Getty Images |
For the Classicist: The Dill BLP This is the most direct upgrade. Thinly sliced classic dill pickles provide a bright, herbal note and a sharp acidity that mirrors the tomato's role but with more character.
Pro-Tip: Double down on the flavor. Make a dill mayo by adding finely chopped fresh dill, a little black pepper, and a teaspoon of the pickle brine itself into your mayonnaise.
For the Sweet & Salty Fan: The Bread & Butter BLP This is a complete game-changer. Using sweet pickles, like Bread & Butter chips, creates a stunning, sharp contrast against the smoky, salty bacon. The flavor profile moves satisfyingly close to that of candied bacon, giving you a sweet-and-savory masterpiece.
For the Garlic Lover: The Kosher Dill BLP Grab a jar of garlicky kosher pickles. The robust garlic flavor fundamentally changes the sandwich.
Pro-Tip: Lean into it. Make a quick garlic aioli (or simply fold roasted garlic paste into your mayo) to tie the entire sandwich together.
For the Heat-Seeker: The Spicy BLP This is where the BLP truly leaves the BLT in the dust. Use spicy pickles whether they're jalapeño-infused, habanero-brined, or simply chili-flaked.
Pro-Tip: Create a spicy, smoky sriracha or chipotle mayo to boost the heat and add another layer of complexity.
Think Beyond the Cucumber
"Pickle" doesn't have to mean pickled cucumber. This is your chance to get creative.
Pickled Red Onions: Add a beautiful color, a satisfying crunch, and a tangy bite that perfectly cuts the bacon's fat.
Pickled Jalapeños: Bring a focused, bright heat and zesty flavor without the overwhelming vinegar of a Tabasco-style sauce.
Pickled Banana Peppers: Offer a mild, tangy crunch that pairs beautifully with almost any variation.
The BLT is a classic. But it's a classic that lives in fear of winter. The BLP is consistent, it's bold, and it's infinitely customizable. It just might be the new favorite sandwich you never knew you were missing.